Police chief cites 'lack of supervision' as major problem in beating of Black man caught on camera
Two more Memphis, Tenn., police officers have been disciplined and three emergency responders fired in connection with the death of Tyre Nichols, officials said Monday, widening the circle of punishment beyond the officers who violently beat the Black man during a traffic stop to those who failed to help him after.
Officer Preston Hemphill, who is white, was relieved of duty shortly after the 19-year-old FedEx worker's Jan. 7 arrest, the police department announced Monday. Later in the day Memphis police said another officer had also been relieved of duty, but did not name the person or specify what role they played in the incident.
That brought the total number of Memphis officers who have been disciplined to seven, including the five Black officers who were fired and charged last week with second-degree murder and other offences in Nichols's beating and Jan. 10 death.
Also Monday, Memphis Fire Department officials announced the dismissal of emergency medical technicians Robert Long and JaMicheal Sandridge, as well as Lt. Michelle Whitaker.
Fire Chief Gina Sweat said in a statement that the department received a call from police to respond to a report of a person who had been pepper-sprayed. The workers arrived at 8:41 p.m. as Nichols was handcuffed on the ground and slumped against a squad car, the statement said.
Based on the nature of the call and information they were told by police, Long and Sandridge "failed to conduct an adequate patient assessment of Mr. Nichols," the statement said.
An ambulance was called, and it arrived at 8:55 p.m., the statement said. An emergency unit cared for Nichols and left for a hospital with him at 9:08 p.m. — 27 minutes after Long, Sandridge and Whitaker arrived, officials said.
An investigation determined that all three violated "multiple" policies and protocols, the statement said, adding that "their actions or inactions on the scene that night do not meet the expectations of the Memphis Fire Department."
Memphis police 'haven't risen to the occasion'
The killing of Nichols has led to days of public discussion of how police forces treat Black citizens with excessive violence, regardless of the race of either the police officers or those being policed.
On body camera footage from the initial stop, Hemphill is heard saying that he stunned Nichols and declaring, "I hope they stomp his ass."
Memphis Police Department officers used a stun gun, a baton and their fists as they pummeled Nichols during the nighttime arrest.
Video shows Nichols running from officers toward his house after he was pulled over on suspicion of reckless driving. Nichols, a 29-year-old father, was heard calling for his mother as he struggled with his injuries as sat helpless on the pavement, video footage released Friday showed.
The five officers chatted and milled about for several minutes as Nichols remained on the ground, but there were other authorities on the scene. Two Shelby County sheriff's deputies have been relieved of duty without pay while their conduct is investigated.
In the Nichols case, the police department has been responsible for internal disciplinary measures, such as firings, while the Shelby County district attorney has handled the criminal charges.
Hemphill was the third officer at a traffic stop that preceded the violent arrest, but he was not at the scene where Nichols was beaten, his lawyer Lee Gerald said, noting that Hemphill turned on his body camera, in line with department policy.
Lawyers for the Nichols family on Monday questioned why the department did not disclose Hemphill's discipline earlier and asked why he had not been fired or charged.
"We have asked from the beginning that the Memphis Police Department be transparent with the family and the community — this news seems to indicate that they haven't risen to the occasion," attorneys Ben Crump and Anthony Romanucci said in a statement. "It certainly begs the question why the white officer involved in this brutal attack was shielded and protected from the public eye, and to date, from sufficient discipline and accountability."
Memphis police spokesperson Karen Rudolph said information on disciplinary action taken against Hemphill was not immediately released because Hemphill was not fired.
The department generally gives out information about an officer's punishment only after a department investigation into misconduct ends, Rudolph said.
Lack of supervision 'a major problem,' chief says
Memphis Police Director Cerelyn "CJ" Davis told The Associated Press in an interview Friday that a "lack of supervision in this incident was a major problem."
"When officers are working, you should have at least one supervisor for every group or squad of people," Davis said. "Not just somebody who's at the office doing the paperwork, somebody who's actually embedded in that unit."
Calls for more officers to be fired or charged have been loud and persistent from the Nichols family, their lawyers and community activists who have peacefully protested in Memphis since the video was released. The video was evocative of the arrest of George Floyd in 2020 and officers' failure to intervene.
The death of Tyre Nichols, who died after being beaten by police in Memphis, has prompted renewed calls for police reform in the United States.
On Saturday, Nichols's stepfather, Rodney Wells, told The Associated Press that the family was going to "continue to seek justice and get some more officers arrested."
"Questions were raised before the video was released, I raised those questions," Wells said. "I just felt there was more than five officers out there. Now, five were charged with murder because they were the main participants, but there were five or six other officers out there that didn't do anything to render any aid. So they are just as culpable as the officers who threw the blows."
More officers should be disciplined: councillor
Memphis City Council member Martavius Jones said Monday that police policies on rendering aid and de-escalation appeared to have been violated.
"When everybody saw the video, we see that you have multiple officers just standing around, when Mr. Nichols is in distress, that just paints a totally different picture," he said.
Jones said he believes more officers should be disciplined.
"At this point, what's going to be helpful for this community is to see how swiftly the police chief deals with those other officers now that everybody has seen the tape and knows that is wasn't only five officers who were at the scene the entire time," he said.
The five fired officers and Hemphill were part of the so-called Scorpion unit, which targeted violent criminals in high-crime areas. Davis, the police chief, said Saturday that the unit has been disbanded.
A funeral service for Nichols is scheduled for Wednesday at a Memphis church.
Credit belongs to : www.cbc.ca