Random Image Display on Page Reload

An Alleged Deepfake of UK Opposition Leader Keir Starmer Shows the Dangers of Fake Audio

Oct 9, 2023 11:30 AM

Deepfake Audio Is a Political Nightmare

British fact-checkers are racing to debunk a suspicious audio recording of UK opposition leader Keir Starmer.

Keir Starmer

Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty Images

As members of the UK’s largest opposition party gathered in Liverpool for their party conference—probably their last before the UK holds a general election—a potentially explosive audio file started circulating on X, formerly known as Twitter.

The 25-second recording was posted by an X account with the handle “@Leo_Hutz” that was set up in January 2023. In the clip, Sir Keir Starmer, the Labour Party leader, is apparently heard swearing repeatedly at a staffer. “I have obtained audio of Keir Starmer verbally abusing his staffers at [the Labour Party] conference,” the X account posted. “This disgusting bully is about to become our next PM.”

It’s unclear whether the audio recording is real, AI-generated, or recorded using an impersonator. British fact-checking organization Full Fact said it is still investigating. “As we’re talking now, it can’t be validated one way or the other. But there are characteristics of it that point to it being a fake,” says Glen Tarman, Full Fact’s head of advocacy and policy. “There’s a phrase which appears to be repeated, rather than [using] a different intonation the second time it’s used, and there’s a few glitches in the background noise.”

Audio deepfakes are emerging as a major risk to the democratic process, as the UK—and more than 50 other countries—move toward elections in 2024. Manipulating audio content is becoming cheaper and easier, while fact-checkers say it’s difficult to quickly and definitively identify a recording as fake. These recordings could spend hours or days floating around social media before they’re debunked, and researchers worry that this type of deepfake content could create a political atmosphere in which voters don’t know what information they can trust.

“If you are listening to a sound bite or a video online with this seed of doubt about whether this is genuinely real, it risks undermining the foundation of how debate happens and people’s capacity to feel informed,” says Kate Dommett, professor of digital politics at Sheffield University.

X’s manipulated media policy states that videos or audios that have been deceptively altered or manipulated should be labeled or removed. Neither has happened to the post, and X did not reply to WIRED’s request for comment on whether the platform has investigated the recording’s authenticity.

Most Popular

Starmer’s team has yet to comment. But several MPs from the ruling Conservative party called the recording a deepfake. “There’s a fake audio recording of Keir Starmer going around,” MP Tom Tugendhat said on X. “The last 30 years of public life has seen a catastrophic undermining of faith in institutions, for good and bad reasons,” Matt Warman, another Conservative MP, posted. “But today’s Sir Keir Starmer deepfake is a new low, supercharged by AI and social media. Democracy is under real threat—technology to verify content is essential.”

The incident comes a week after a scandal in the final hours of Slovakia’s election campaign, when an audio recording was released on Facebook that appeared to show the leader of the opposition Progressive Slovakia party talking about his plans to rig the election. Michal Šimečka denounced that audio as fake, and AFP’s fact-checking department said the audio showed signs of manipulation. At the time, fact-checkers said they felt ill-equipped to definitively debunk AI-generated audio recordings.

Countries around the world are struggling with how to respond to audio recordings that are deemed fake. Alleged deepfake recordings have been causing confusion in both Sudan and India. In Sudan, “leaked recordings” of former leader Omar al-Bashir, who hasn’t been seen in public for a year, were suspected of being manipulated. In India, an audio recording was released of Palanivel Thiagarajan, an opposition politician, allegedly accusing his fellow party members of corruption. Thiagarajan said the recording was machine-generated.

The problem of easy-to-create deepfake media is compounded by the fact that detection tools are not widely available, says Sam Gregory, executive director at Witness, a human rights group that focuses on technology. “There is no shared standard for adding watermarks or provenance signals to AI-generated deepfake audio, just efforts by single companies. It’s no use having a tool to spot whether content is generated by one company when the same tool would give a false negative on fake audio created by one of the many other tools on the market.”

The inability to definitively prove the authenticity of an audio recording is adding murkiness that will also be exploited by politicians featured in real audio, adds Gregory. “Politicians will claim that real audio is faked and put the pressure on fact-checkers to debunk this claim, when they lack the tools or the speedy capacity to do this.”

You Might Also Like …

Morgan Meaker is a senior writer at WIRED covering European business. Before that, she was a technology reporter at The Telegraph and also worked for Dutch magazine De Correspondent. In 2019 she won Technology Journalist of the Year at the Words by Women Awards. She was born in Scotland, lives… Read more
Senior Writer

More from WIRED

A Doctored Biden Video Is a Test Case for Facebook’s Deepfake Policies

Meta’s Oversight Board is reviewing Facebook’s decision not to remove a manipulated video posted during the US midterms, in an attempt to get it to clarify its policies on election deepfakes.

Vittoria Elliott

The Auto Strike Threatens a Supply Chain Already Weakened by Covid

A prolonged autoworker strike would be especially painful for smaller players inside the complex auto supply chain. It could also impact thousands more workers and push up car prices.

Aarian Marshall

X Challenger Pebble Thinks AI-Generated Posts Can Help Lure Users Away From Elon Musk

To encourage conversation, Twitter-like platform Pebble—formerly T2—now suggests AI-generated updates for users to edit or post. It's also opening sign-ups to anyone with an account on X.

Paresh Dave

Idris Elba Is Ready to Talk About Crypto

During the crypto gold rush, Idris Elba says he turned down a lot of “mad opportunities.” Now he has partnered with the “crypto-for-good” Stellar Foundation.

Joel Khalili

FedEx’s New Robot Loads Delivery Trucks Like It’s Playing 3D Tetris

FedEx handles over 15 million packages daily. A two-armed, AI-infused robot is now helping pack some of them into delivery trucks with expert care.

Will Knight

The Global Victims of FTX’s Collapse Won’t Get their Day in Court

FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried is about to stand trial in the US. But many customers who lost big when the exchange collapsed are unlikely to get their money back.

Parth M.N.

AI Hurricane Predictions Are Storming the World of Weather Forecasting

This year’s hurricane season provides a test run for the idea that machine-learning algorithms can improve weather forecasts. So far, the AI models are making good calls.

Gregory Barber

Sam Bankman-Fried Is a Terrible Client

Criminal defendants often decline to testify at trial for fear of incriminating themselves. For FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried, that could be the best option.

Joel Khalili

*****
Credit belongs to : www.wired.com

Check Also

High-tech London, Ont.-area farm delivers fresh produce all year. Could it be an answer to high grocery costs?

At a farm north of London, Ont., researchers with Western University are planting the seeds …