Random Image Display on Page Reload

Elon Musk Is No Climate Hero

Aug 16, 2024 9:00 AM

Elon Musk Is No Climate Hero

During a live interview with Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, the former president literally said, “Drill, baby, drill.” Musk met the statement with … silence.

Elon Musk in a suit looking down

Photograph: Samuel Corum; Bloomberg/Getty

WIRED has been writing about Elon Musk—he of the electric cars, space rockets, tunnel-boring machines, implantable brain interfaces, Mars mission, and internetshitposting—for a longtime. He’s always been unpredictable. And yet the most shocking part of his two-hour interview with Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, broadcast live on X earlier this week, may just have been what Musk didn’t say.

It happened around the 50-minute mark, during a very Trumpian discussion of gas and electricity prices. They were up nationally, Trump said, but “when that comes down and [sic] we’re going to drill, baby, drill.”

The siren song of the oil and gas industry! Literally: Drill, baby, drill! And Musk, he of the—I’m going to say it again—electric cars and “saving the world” schtick, didn’t pipe up until a full two minutes later, when he suggested that Trump set up a “government efficiency commission” to curb government spending. Later, he and Trump did have a brief exchange on the science of climate change. But Musk took pains to emphasize that the oil and gas industry isn’t the problem. “I’m pro-environment, but … I don’t think we should vilify the oil and gas industry, because they’re keeping civilization going right now,” he said.

This felt like a departure. Musk has spent a large chunk of his career casting himself as an environmental champion, sometimes going so far as to paint himself as the one man standing between the world and disaster. He has told the story of Tesla, in particular, as a hero’s journey to save the world through a transition to a sustainable energy economy. “I think I am objectively one of the world's leading environmentalists in terms of doing things,” he said at an Italian political event last December.

In 2017, Musk told Rolling Stone about the clear existential threat of climate change with a flair that still feels familiar. “Climate change is the biggest threat that humanity faces this century, except for AI,” he said. “I keep telling people this. I hate to be Cassandra here, but it’s all fun and games until somebody loses a fucking eye. This view [of climate change] is shared by almost everyone who’s not crazy in the scientific community.” Musk has also regularly accused critics of carrying water for “fossil fuel companies.”

Oh, and remember that time (June 2017) that Musk quit three of Trump’s presidential councils after the US pulled out of the Paris climate accords? “Climate change is real,” he tweeted at the time. “Leaving Paris is not good for America or the world.”

Musk’s newer and wishy-washy approach to climate also reflects not only his very vocal embrace of far-right politics but also a new story he’s telling about Tesla. For the past few years, and especially as the chatter around artificial intelligence has hit a fever pitch, Musk has positioned his electric-auto maker as a path-breaker in robotic intelligence, too. In 2019, Musk announced that Tesla would have 1 million robotaxis on the road by the end of the year. (It didn’t). More recently, Tesla reportedly shifted resources from building a more affordable electric car, the mythical Model 2, to releasing a purpose-built robotaxi, even though the company has yet to reveal any true self-driving technology. (An unveiling event is scheduled for October.) Musk has said repeatedly that Tesla is an AI and robotics company and should be valued by investors as such. If Musk is backing off his endorsement of climate change science, it’s reasonable to ask if that relates to his marketing pivot for the most valuable car company in the world.

That said, Musk and Trump did have a quasi-substantive conversation about climate change. In it, Musk told Trump that “we do, over time, want to move to a sustainable energy economy, because eventually you run out of oil and gas.” (On Monday, Trump agreed with Musk—and then spent a chunk of a Thursday press conference railing against electric trucks.) Musk emphasized that high levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere leads to “headaches and nausea.”

That’s not wrong, exactly. Researchers have found that indoor exposure to highconcentrations of carbon dioxide, around the 1,000-parts-per-million mark (or higher), can make people ill. But Musk omitted the most adverse effects of high concentrations of carbon dioxide: that gas traps the sun’s heat nearer to the Earth’s surface, intensifying rain storms, heat waves, even disease outbreaks. This stuff is happening now. Which means that Musk’s assessment Monday of the US approach to climate change—”we still have quite a bit of time”—misses the mark.


Image may contain Label Text Symbol and Sign

Time Travel

Much has been made of Musk’s recent shift rightward. But even when he and his electric-car company were the bogeymen of right-wing media, Musk’s politics were never straightforward. He has, for years, caught the ire of pro-labor progressives for his fight against unionization at Tesla’s California plant. (Just this week, the United Auto Workers filed federal labor charges against Musk and Trump for anti-union comments made during the interview.) The man has never pretended to be pro-worker.

In a 2018 WIRED cover story, writer Charles Duhigg uncovered the distinctly unpleasant working conditions during Tesla’s push to produce its “most affordable” vehicle yet, the Model 3 sedan. The whole thing is worth a read, but an opening anecdote showed just how passionate, capricious, and downright rude to employees Musk can be. How you feel about that probably comes down to how you feel about Musk, and his various missions, in general.

At about 10 o’clock on Saturday evening, an angry Musk was examining one of the production line’s mechanized modules, trying to figure out what was wrong, when the young, excited engineer was brought over to assist him.

“Hey, buddy, this doesn’t work!” Musk shouted at the engineer, according to someone who heard the conversation. “Did you do this?”

The engineer was taken aback. He had never met Musk before. Musk didn’t even know the engineer’s name. The young man wasn’t certain what, exactly, Musk was asking him, or why he sounded so angry.

“You mean, program the robot?” the engineer said. “Or design that tool?”

“Did you fucking do this?” Musk asked him.

“I’m not sure what you’re referring to?” the engineer replied apologetically.

“You’re a fucking idiot!” Musk shouted back. “Get the fuck out and don’t come back!”

The young engineer climbed over a low safety barrier and walked away. He was bewildered by what had just happened. The entire conversation had lasted less than a minute. A few moments later, his manager came over to say that he had been fired on Musk’s orders, according to two people with knowledge of the situation. The engineer was shocked. He’d been working so hard. He was set to get a review from his manager the next week, and had been hearing only positive things. Instead, two days later, he signed his separation papers.


Image may contain Symbol

End Times Chronicle

The oceans are weirdly warm right now. Climate change probably has a lot to do with it, but so might … general weirdness?


Image may contain Label Text Symbol and Sign

Last but Not Least

Your visual guide to the influencers shaping the 2024 election. (Guess who the biggest political influencer is?!)

But not all influencers successfully influence. Why NBC’s Olympics bet didn't quite work out.

If you value your neck, please update your bicycle’s gear-shifter software.

If you value your mental health, don’t get too attached to OpenAI’s voice mode. (The company says it’s a risk.)


Image may contain Logo Symbol Trademark Text and Label

Don't miss future subscriber-only editions of this column.Subscribe to WIRED (50% off for Plaintext readers)today.

Aarian Marshall is a staff writer covering transportation and cities. Before joining WIRED, she wrote for The Atlantic’s CityLab. Marshall is based in Seattle, where she’s learning to love rain.
Staff Writer

Read More

The Paris Olympics Promised Flying Taxis—Here’s Why They Failed to Launch

Futuristic plans for tourists to fly over Paris stalled as critics derided flying taxis as an “absurd” invention that will “only benefit a few ultrarich people.”
Morgan Meaker

Here’s What the Inside of an Airbus Factory Looks Like

In Hamburg, aviation giant Airbus is transforming aircraft production with state-of-the-art robotics technology on its planes. We go on a behind-the-scenes visit for the delivery of an A321neo.
Antonio Dini

Israel Is Buying Google Ads to Discredit the UN’s Top Gaza Aid Agency

The UNRWA calls Israel’s strategy of promoting alleged misinformation “destructive.”
Paresh Dave

Telegram Founder Pavel Durov Charged Over Alleged Criminal Activity on the App

After four days in the custody of French police, Telegram’s CEO has been charged with complicity in spreading sexual images of children and other alleged crimes.
Morgan Meaker

Telegram CEO Pavel Durov’s Arrest Linked to Sweeping Criminal Investigation

French authorities detained Durov to question him as part of a probe into a wide range of alleged violations—including money laundering and CSAM—but it remains unclear if he will face charges.
Lily Hay Newman

Generative AI Transformed English Homework. Math Is Next

ByteDance’s Gauth app scans math homework and provides thorough, often correct, answers using AI. Millions have already downloaded it for free.
Reece Rogers

Pavel Durov’s Arrest Leaves Telegram Hanging in the Balance

Durov has reportedly been detained in France over Telegram’s alleged failure to adequately moderate illegal content on the messaging app. His arrest sparked backlash and left some associates asking, what now?
Darren Loucaides

Will the ‘Car-Free’ Los Angeles Olympics Work?

Organizers of the 2028 Summer Games will attempt to re-create the city’s public transport heyday of the early 20th century, but ousting the car—even for just a few weeks—will be costly.
Jay L. Zagorsky

*****
Credit belongs to : www.wired.com

Check Also

AI tool cuts unexpected deaths in hospital by 26%, Canadian study finds

A year-and-a-half-long study on Chartwatch, an artificial intelligence system in use at St. Michael's Hospital …