Random Image Display on Page Reload

The US Sues Apple in an iPhone Antitrust Blockbuster

Mar 21, 2024 11:08 AM

The US Sues Apple in an iPhone Antitrust Blockbuster

The Department of Justice lawsuit is the most aggressive legal challenge yet to Apple’s dominant ecosystem.

Signage and a crowd of people outside of an Apple Store

Photograph: SeongJoon Cho/Getty Images

The US Department of Justice, along with more than a dozen state attorneys general, has filed a lawsuit against Apple that takes direct aim at the iPhone and the company’s lucrative iOS ecosystem.

Claiming that Apple had established an “iPhone monopoly,” the suit argues that the company’s allegedly anticompetitive behavior resounds well beyond smartphones themselves. It cites financial services, fitness, gaming, media, and more as industries affected by Apple’s “walled garden” approach.

“This case is about freeing smartphone markets from Apple’s anticompetitive and exclusionary conduct and restoring competition to lower smartphone prices for consumers, reducing fees for developers, and preserving innovation for the future,” the suit claims.

Apple’s App Store has been a particular point of contention for years. The company has faced legal challenges, most notably from Fortnite developer Epic Games, over both its restrictiveness and the fees it charges developers for in-app purchases. The App Store is a focal point of the suit, a key component of the allegedly anticompetitive “moat” the company has built around its products.

The suit directly seeks to prevent Apple from “using its control of app distribution to undermine cross-platform technologies such as super apps and cloud streaming apps, among others,” stop the company from “using private APIs to undermine cross-platform technologies like messaging, smart watches, and digital wallets,” and end Apple's alleged practice of “using the terms and conditions of its contracts with developers, accessory makers, consumers, or others to obtain, maintain, extend, or entrench a monopoly.”

“This lawsuit threatens who we are and the principles that set Apple products apart in fiercely competitive markets,” Apple said in an emailed statement. "If successful, it would hinder our ability to create the kind of technology people expect from Apple—where hardware, software, and services intersect. It would also set a dangerous precedent, empowering government to take a heavy hand in designing people’s technology. We believe this lawsuit is wrong on the facts and the law, and we will vigorously defend against it.”

Antitrust enforcement has been a key focus of the Biden administration. In 2021 the White House issued an executive order meant to encourage stronger enforcement of existing antitrust laws via the Federal Trade Commission and Justice Department, and created the White House Competition Council. “Polls show that the public is truly concerned that the federal government should do more about the power of monopolies in order to make the economy more fair and competitive,” Timothy Wu, former special assistant to the president for technology and competition, said in a speech in November 2021.

“Over the last two decades Apple has become one of the most successful companies in the world,” US attorney general Merrick Garland said in a press conference Thursday morning, noting that the company is bigger than the individual GDP of more than 100 countries. Garland alleges that in order to maintain its grip on the market, “Apple knowingly and deliberately degrades quality and security for its users” and stifles innovation.

Jonathan Kanter, the assistant attorney general leading the Justice Department’s antitrust division, said at the press conference that Apple was a “significant beneficiary” of the antitrust case against Microsoft more than two decades ago, which Kanter said allowed for the kind of competition and innovation that allowed Apple to flourish. Kanter said that the Justice Department had uncovered a “pattern of anticompetitive conduct by Apple,” where the company made it harder for developers and customers to leave its ecosystem, “rather than more attractive to stay.”

The US lawsuit against Apple comes amid intensifying regulatory scrutiny in the European Union, where the Digital Markets Act recently went into effect. The DMA, which imposes new rules on tech companies in an attempt to foster greater competition in digital markets, forced Apple to allow users of its products to download apps from third-party app stores. The first of these competing app stores will likely be launched by Epic Games. The day before the DMA went into effect, on March 6, Apple banned Epic’s developer account, only to reinstate it two days later.

The Justice Department, too, has been active in this space. It brought an antitrust case against Google last year for its monopoly of digital advertising. In September, the FTC announced it was suing Amazon, alleging that the company had manipulated its search results to punish sellers who offered prices lower than Amazon’s own products, and forced sellers to use the company’s own fulfillment services, amongst others.

Apple has already faced down some of these questions in court and won. In January, the Supreme Court declined to hear Epic's appeal of the parts of the case against Apple that it lost. And the company has already made some changes to its App Store policies in response to, and anticipation of, legal threats.

Additional reporting by Andrew Couts.

Vittoria Elliott is a reporter for WIRED, covering platforms and power. She was previously a reporter at Rest of World, where she covered disinformation and labor in markets outside the US and Western Europe. She has worked with The New Humanitarian, Al Jazeera, and ProPublica. She is a graduate of… Read more
Platforms and power reporter

    Brian Barrett is the executive editor of news at WIRED, overseeing day to day coverage across the site. Prior to WIRED he was the editor in chief of the tech and culture site Gizmodo and was a business reporter for the Yomiuri Shimbun, Japan’s largest daily newspaper.
    Executive Editor, News

    More from WIRED

    The US Claims Apple Has a Stranglehold on the Future

    The Department of Justice antitrust lawsuit against Apple says the company’s grip on iPhone users and developers is blocking future innovation in tech.

    Makena Kelly

    The Apple Antitrust Case and the ‘Stigma’ of the Green Bubble

    The US government's Apple lawsuit leans on the social cost of not owning an iPhone, an unusual argument for antitrust.

    Lauren Goode

    The EU Targets Apple, Meta, and Alphabet for Investigations Under New Tech Law

    The probes are the first to take place under Europe’s landmark Digital Markets Act—and add to Apple’s mounting antitrust woes.

    Morgan Meaker

    4 Internal Apple Emails That Helped the DOJ Build Its Case

    The Department of Justice alleges in its antitrust lawsuit that internal Apple emails show the company intentionally locks in users, forcing them to spend more money.

    Tom Simonite

    Apple Could Be the First Target of Europe’s Tough New Tech Law

    An architect of the EU’s tough new Digital Markets Acts says Apple would be a logical first candidate for investigation under the law, which aims to “break open” tech platforms.

    Morgan Meaker

    Europe Is Breaking Open the Empires of Big Tech

    Tech giants have to comply with a new EU law that is set to change the internet. It aims to force open the biggest platforms to encourage competition and give users more choice in their digital lives.

    Morgan Meaker

    Apple Fined $2 Billion as Europe Sides With Spotify

    Music streaming service Spotify has long complained that Apple’s App Store rules put unfair restrictions on its business. Today the European Commission agreed, fining Apple $2 billion.

    Morgan Meaker

    Apple’s MM1 AI Model Shows a Sleeping Giant Is Waking Up

    A research paper quietly released by Apple describes an AI model called MM1 that can answer questions and analyze images. It’s the biggest sign yet that Apple is developing generative AI capabilities.

    Will Knight

    *****
    Credit belongs to : www.wired.com

    Check Also

    Google Workers Protest Cloud Contract With Israel’s Government

    Caroline Haskins Business Apr 16, 2024 1:09 PM Google Workers Protest Cloud Contract With Israel's …